In "On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft," Stephen King shares his thoughts on the effectiveness of writers' workshop critiques. He expresses disappointment in how these critiques often lack specificity and clarity. Many critiques seem to be frustratingly vague, leaving writers without clear guidance on how to improve their work. King suggests that if a participant struggles to articulate their feelings about a piece, they might not be in the right setting for constructive feedback.

King's reflections reveal a broader concern about the nature of writing workshops. He implies that attendees need to engage meaningfully and provide insights that are useful for fellow writers. The emphasis should be on constructive criticism that helps writers grow, rather than vague suggestions that can confuse rather than enlighten. Ultimately, King advocates for a more direct and thoughtful approach to critique in the writing process.