I think many people are terribly afraid of being demoted by the Darwinian scheme from the role of authors and creators in their own right into being just places where things happen in the universe.
This quote highlights a profound concern about how the worldview influenced by Darwinian theory can diminish the sense of human agency and creativity. Many individuals like to see themselves as active architects of their own lives, responsible for their choices and innovations. However, embracing a strictly Darwinian perspective might suggest that much of what happens to us is dictated by natural selection, genetic inheritance, and unconscious processes rather than conscious intent. This can evoke a fear of losing moral and intellectual autonomy, feeling relegated to mere biological or environmental responses rather than true authors of their destiny.
Understanding ourselves as creators and authors of our experiences imbues life with purpose and dignity. When we internalize a narrative where external forces and evolutionary processes predominate, it can lead to a sense of futility or detachment from personal responsibility. Nevertheless, this perspective isn't necessarily in opposition to human agency; instead, it encourages a nuanced view where natural processes form the foundation upon which human creativity and consciousness operate.
The fear articulated in the quote might stem from a discomfort with acknowledging these underlying mechanisms. Yet, recognizing the influence of natural laws can also empower a more empathetic and realistic understanding of human nature. It allows us to appreciate our minds as complex products of evolution, capable of reflection, innovation, and purpose, despite their biological roots. Ultimately, balancing acknowledgment of our evolutionary history with a sense of personal authorship could lead to a richer, more resilient identity that honors both our origins and our capacity for creativity.