In Kim Edwards' "The Memory Keeper's Daughter," Caroline clings to a romantic ideal that David Henry understands her in a unique and profound way. This belief, rooted in a deep emotional connection, reflects her desire for intimacy and recognition. However, the reality is starkly different; David has never truly seen or understood her. This disconnect highlights Caroline's longing for a bond that is ultimately unfulfilled.

The narrative uncovers the bittersweet nature of unreciprocated feelings and the complexities of relationships. Caroline's misguided hope serves as a poignant reminder of the emotional distance that can exist between people, even those who are close. Her realization that David is unaware of her true self adds depth to her character, underscoring themes of isolation and the search for meaningful connections in life.