Gore Vidal critiques the statement made by President Bush regarding the state of war, emphasizing that a true declaration of war requires Congressional approval. He argues that without this formal vote, the concept of being "at war" is misleading. Vidal highlights the importance of constitutional procedures in declaring war, suggesting that the current situation blurs the lines of legality and legitimacy.

Vidal also points out the notion of a "war on terror," questioning the effectiveness and clarity of this phrase. By framing the conflict in this manner, he believes it obscures real issues and creates a state of perpetual conflict that lacks defined objectives. The author urges a return to lawful practices in matters of war and peace.