In this passage from "Outlander" by Diana Gabaldon, a character expresses their disapproval of the harsh method of discipline represented by physical punishment. They argue that such violence is an uncivilized way to impose authority, suggesting that there should be more humane methods of teaching respect and obedience. The speaker believes that inflicting pain is contrary to civilized behavior.

The response they receive is dismissive and authoritative. The elder criticizes the speaker's reasoning and emphasizes the importance of respecting one's elders as a fundamental aspect of societal norms. This underscores a generational divide in perspectives on discipline and respect, framing the elder's viewpoint as one rooted in tradition and unquestioned authority.