In the dialogue between Peridan and Edmund from "The Horse and His Boy," Peridan argues that a violent assault warrants severe punishment, equating the aggressor with an assassin. He believes that such actions deserve the utmost consequences, highlighting a strict viewpoint on justice.

Edmund, however, counters this perspective by suggesting that even traitors can change for the better. His contemplative stance reflects a belief in redemption and the possibility of forgiveness, illustrating a more nuanced understanding of human nature and morality. This exchange showcases the tension between justice and mercy, a central theme in the narrative.