In Sinclair Lewis's "It Can't Happen Here," the author explores the nature of American identity, suggesting that the nation has never fully embraced a gay culture. Instead, America has often been characterized by a loud and humorous demeanor, masking deeper feelings of anxiety and insecurity. This duality mirrors the complexities of its historical figures, particularly Lincoln, who embodied both the spirit of jovial storytelling and profound tragedy.

Lewis's observation highlights the tension in American society between outward expressions of joy and underlying struggles with acceptance and self-perception. This critique reflects broader societal issues, indicating how America's public persona often contrasts with its private emotional landscape.