Initially, Preacher's actions seemed driven by a strong desire to correct injustices and protect those he cared about, reflecting his tough exterior and softer inner self. His values of justice and loyalty were crucial to him, marking his character as someone deeply committed to doing what is right. However, as time passed, it became evident that his feelings for Paige transcended simple loyalty, indicating a shift in his emotional landscape.

Preacher's watchful gaze on Paige revealed an intensity that hinted at deeper, unexplored emotions. His eyes would darken when he looked at her, showcasing a mixture of conflict and longing. This shift in his feelings caused him to grapple with unfamiliar emotions, leading him to look away as if trying to find clarity in feelings he had never experienced before.