Port Royal, despite its notorious reputation, was remarkable for its inclusivity, allowing various faiths such as Quakers, Catholics, atheists, and Jews to coexist peacefully. This atmosphere of tolerance contributed to its emergence as the wealthiest town in the New World, where diverse beliefs thrived without conflict. People of different backgrounds harnessed the benefits of their communal living, transforming the town into a vibrant cultural hub.
The arrival of pirates and buccaneers added to Port Royal's charm, as locals embraced these adventurers who significantly contributed to the town's prosperity. The residents recognized the pirates as integral to their fortune and celebrated their lifestyles, forming a unique community atmosphere where revelry and commerce intertwined, enriching their cultural landscape.