In "Pirate Hunters: Treasure, Obsession and the Search for a Legendary Pirate Ship," Robert Kurson explores the significant role that reputation played among pirates. Their notoriety often served as a formidable tool, functioning like a weapon that could instill fear and command respect from others on the high seas. A well-crafted reputation could allow pirates to avoid unnecessary conflict and bolster their standing among peers and adversaries alike.

Kurson emphasizes that a pirate's reputation was essential for their survival and success in a harsh and competitive environment. The phrase "Reputation became the pirates' sharpest sword" underlines how crucial it was for pirates to cultivate an image that would both intimidate their foes and attract potential crew members. This dynamic illustrates the psychological warfare inherent in piracy during its heyday, highlighting how perception could wield more power than physical force.