This quote from Dean Koontz's Brother Odd ironically highlights the paradox in human nature, where skepticism and gullibility coexist. It points out a contradictory behavior in people who claim disbelief — in anything at all — yet readily accept bizarre or sensational stories about certain groups. This observation invites us to reflect on the selective nature of belief and mistrust. People may reject established truths or commonly accepted ideas, but simultaneously, they exhibit a readiness to embrace the unusual or outlandish when it pertains to others, especially those who are marginalized or perceived as different.

This contradiction serves as a mirror on societal biases, showing how judgments and stereotypes can easily override critical thinking. It suggests that the absence of belief does not equate to open-mindedness or impartiality; rather, it may camouflage other forms of prejudice—prejudice wrapped in cynicism or incredulity. Furthermore, the phrase "people like us" creates a sense of community among those unfairly targeted by misinformation, emphasizing the lived experiences of alienation and misunderstanding.

On a broader level, this quote challenges readers to question their own assumptions and the sources of their beliefs—encouraging a more cautious and compassionate approach to stories about others. It reminds us that true skepticism should be consistent and balanced, applied equally to dismissive attitudes and uncritical credulity alike. Ultimately, it compels thoughtful introspection about how narratives are formed and why certain voices are believed more readily than others.