Grigsby had looked at him askance. "Why is it," he said, "that I have the distinct impression you're not surprised by this news?"'Surprised by the fact that the reverend is first and foremost a human being? Surprised by the fact that every human being, reverend or ribald, can be undone by capricious circumstances? Or should I be surprised by the fact that a man who teaches love and forgiveness can love and forgive? Tell me, Marmy, exactly what it is I should be surprised at?
In this exchange, Grigsby expresses skepticism about the reaction to certain news, hinting that he feels the person he is speaking to is not genuinely shocked. The dialogue suggests a deeper understanding of human nature, particularly in relation to the flaws and vulnerabilities that everyone possesses, regardless of their status or role in society. The mention of a reverend adds a layer of irony, as it highlights the contrast between the ideals of love and forgiveness and the realities of human imperfection.
The speaker challenges Grigsby's expectations, questioning why one should be shocked by the fallibility of a revered figure. They underline the idea that being human inherently involves experiencing unpredictable circumstances that can lead to mistakes or moral lapses. By doing so, the dialogue reflects on the universal themes of compassion and understanding, emphasizing that even those who preach virtue can struggle with their humanity.
