In this passage from Wuthering Heights, two characters express contrasting visions of what their ideal existence or "heaven" would be like. One longs for a serene, peaceful state where everything lies in calm and tranquility, while the other desires a lively, joyful celebration filled with sparkle and dance. Their differing visions highlight deep personal differences in how they perceive happiness and fulfillment.
They also critique each other's ideals, with one claiming the other's heaven would be only half alive, and the other saying his heaven would be drunken. Their exchanges reveal their fundamental disconnect, with one feeling suffocated by the other's peacefulness, and the other feeling unable to breathe in the other's lively paradise. This dialogue underscores their incompatible desires and contrasting outlooks on life and happiness.