James H. Cone's assertion profoundly challenges the traditional frameworks within Christian theology, particularly in the context of America. His question cuts to the core of how theology intersects with social justice and racial realities. In a nation historically marred by profound racial injustices and systemic oppression, to ignore the black struggle for liberation when discussing the gospel is to sidestep a critical and lived reality that cannot be separated from Christian doctrine. Cone pushes theologians and believers alike to reconsider theology not just as abstract metaphysical discourse but as a dynamic tool for liberation and justice.

This quote emphasizes integrity in theology, which for Cone, must mean acknowledging the lived experiences of marginalized communities, especially African Americans. The gospel, with its themes of freedom, deliverance, and hope, has an undeniable connection to oppressed peoples' struggles. Ignoring these connections perpetuates a disconnected, ahistorical, and possibly complicit theology that fails to address or challenge systems of oppression.

In essence, Cone invites us to understand theology as an active, living discipline that should respond to the urgent questions of its context rather than retreat into complacency. The gospel is not a neutral or purely spiritual idea; it is deeply political and liberative, especially within the black struggle for freedom. This perspective redefines theology as a force not only for spiritual salvation but also for societal transformation, making it relevant and vital in ongoing struggles for justice and equality in America.