In L.M. Montgomery's "Anne of the Island," the protagonist expresses a nuanced view on morality and relationships. She suggests that while she wouldn't want to marry someone who is inherently wicked, there is a certain allure to the idea of a partner who possesses a wicked nature but chooses not to act on it. This presents a complex understanding of character, where the potential for wrongdoing exists, but self-restraint defines the individual's true nature.

This quote reflects Anne’s romantic ideals, emphasizing the importance of choice and moral integrity in love. It highlights the tension between passion and virtue, suggesting that a man who can resist his darker impulses is far more appealing than one who is simply good. Ultimately, it captures Anne's longing for a partner who is both exciting and morally grounded.