In Cormac McCarthy's novel "All the Pretty Horses," a central theme is the complex nature of human experience and how adversity shapes individual character. The author expresses skepticism about the notion that facing hardships inherently leads people to become more generous or compassionate. Instead, McCarthy suggests that life’s challenges often reveal deeper truths about human behavior and relationships.

This perspective raises important questions about empathy and altruism. While some might argue that suffering fosters a sense of solidarity and kindness, McCarthy implies that hardships can also lead to self-preservation and detachment. Thus, the character's journey reflects a nuanced understanding of how personal trials impact one's ability to connect with others, emphasizing that hardship does not automatically cultivate charity.