Cormac McCarthy’s "All the Pretty Horses" explores themes of expertise, masculinity, and the disdain for theoretical knowledge. The characters in the novel exhibit a fierce pride in their practical skills, believing that true understanding can only be gained through personal experience. This attitude reflects a broader commentary on the nature of masculinity, where practical knowledge is valued over book learning.
The quote highlights the belief that hands-on experience is superior and that theoretical or second-hand knowledge is often dismissed. This perspective emphasizes a rugged individualism central to the characters’ identities, illustrating their connection to the land and the traditions they uphold.