Rafe portrays himself as a Texan, but this claim doesn't sit right with the narrator, who recalls a previous summer romance with someone from Texas, noting that Rafe's accent doesn't match. His last name hints at a Latino heritage, but his physical features suggest a mix of Native American ancestry. This combination of traits adds layers to his identity, making the narrator question the authenticity of his self-presentation.

Standing slightly taller than Daniel, Rafe exudes an air of rebellion thanks to his black hair that falls past the collar of his leather jacket. His style, which includes worn blue jeans and motorcycle boots, aligns with the archetype of the American Teen Rebel. This visual portrayal contributes to the narrator's intrigue and adds complexity to Rafe's character, suggesting a deeper story beneath the surface of his tough exterior.