The figure of Benny from the airwaves was largely a constructed persona, one that should not have surprised audiences when it was revealed he didn't wear a toupee despite years of humor centered around that idea. His public image was tied to vanity, but his character was much more generous in reality, often tipping well at restaurants and dedicating his time to numerous charitable events. This juxtaposition highlights a complexity in his public persona.

Benny frequently acknowledged the support he received from his colleagues, recognizing their crucial roles in his success. In a 1947 interview with Newsweek, he expressed gratitude towards his writers and fellow performers, showcasing his humility and appreciation. His choice to elevate others rather than focus solely on himself contributed to the charm that endeared him to fans, reinforcing that his mythos was as much about collaboration as it was about personal achievement.