The story begins with Mrs. Rogers and Aunt Myra arriving at a gathering, where Amelia Bedelia is eager to welcome her guests. The playful nature of the children is highlighted as they enthusiastically greet Aunt Myra, emphasizing their excitement during the festive season.
Confusion arises when Mrs. Rogers questions the greeting, only to find out that Amelia Bedelia interpreted the instruction to present "Carols" literally, introducing three children named Carol. Aunt Myra appreciates the delightful twist in the greeting, showcasing Amelia Bedelia's charming misunderstandings and the joyful spirit of the holidays.