D.H. Lawrence's observation in "Studies in Classic American Literature" paints a vivid picture of the American spirit. He portrays it as resilient and tough, suggesting that the essence of the American identity is marked by solitude and determination. This characterization highlights a certain brutality that Lawrence associates with the American experience, hinting that there is a deeper, perhaps darker, side to this individuality and strength.

Lawrence's assertion that this soul has "never yet melted" indicates that, despite challenges, it has remained unyielding. It reflects a cultural ideal that values self-sufficiency and stoicism. This perspective invites readers to consider how these traits influence American culture and identity, shaping behaviors and societal values over time, while simultaneously suggesting an ongoing struggle to connect emotionally with others.