Trotsky believed that the only effective way to prevent desertion among Red Army recruits was through extreme measures. He proposed placing machine guns behind the soldiers and executing those who hesitated to charge towards the enemy. This brutal choice forced the soldiers to confront the grim reality of their situation, where they either faced the threat of death in combat or faced execution by their own ranks. Trotsky dismissed any moral arguments about the sanctity of human life, emphasizing a ruthless military discipline to maintain order and force compliance.

This harsh approach highlighted the desperation and severity of the situation during the tumultuous times of World War I. By taking such radical steps, Trotsky aimed to reinforce the commitment of the troops to their cause despite the dire consequences. His disdain for conventional moral considerations reflected the extreme ideologies at play during the conflict, where the need for survival and power often overshadowed humanitarian principles.