The police force during the time was primarily comprised of Irish immigrants, which influenced its dynamics and operations. An official inquiry into a significant riot revealed that some police officers were involved in aiding the rioters, raising serious concerns about their conduct. Reports surfaced detailing allegations of excessive force by the police, which prompted minimal disciplinary actions, such as reprimands or fines.

Despite these accusations of brutality, the implicated officers remained on the police force, suggesting a systemic issue within the institution. This situation reflects not only the challenges of law enforcement but also the broader social tensions of the period, where the line between upholding the law and participating in civil disorder was blurred.