To agree with Ingold is no to say that everything must be local first and last, nor to deny that there are environmental problems on a planetary scale. It is to say that they are not the planet's problems. They are ours.
Bill Bryson, in his book "Seeing Further: The Story of Science and the Royal Society," emphasizes the distinction between global environmental issues and our personal responsibilities towards them. He aligns with Tim Ingold’s perspective, suggesting that while these problems may exist on a planetary level, it is crucial to recognize them as our individual concerns rather than abstract issues affecting the entire planet. This viewpoint urges a more localized approach to understanding and addressing environmental challenges.
By framing these problems as ours, the text encourages a sense of accountability and active engagement with the environment, as opposed to viewing them as distant or detached crises. Bryson’s insights provoke readers to reflect on how we relate to our surroundings and to take action at the local level to contribute to broader solutions, reinforcing the idea that change begins with individual and community efforts.
