Tolkien acknowledges the unique risks that come with possessing virtues that are disconnected from a moral foundation. His works frequently illustrate a deep-seated belief that evil is more inclined to exploit our virtues than our shortcomings. This idea is echoed throughout his narratives, showcasing how traits such as intelligence, bravery, and loyalty can lead individuals astray when not aligned with a higher moral purpose.

Moreover, Tolkien's characters often reveal how these gifts, instead of being used selflessly, can lead to arrogance or a misguided sense of superiority over others. This suggests that even the most admirable qualities, like righteousness, can be twisted to justify selfish motives or disdain for those perceived as less virtuous. Ultimately, Tolkien's insights serve as a cautionary reminder of the need for virtues to be rooted in goodness to avoid moral corruption.