In the dialogue from "All the Pretty Horses," the speaker expresses frustration at being unable to present their argument, feeling that external circumstances beyond their control do not justify one's situation. The acknowledgment of fate and bad luck is noted, but the speaker insists that these elements shouldn't factor positively into one's case. Their stance appears harsh, as they hold a clear distinction between deserving sympathy and merely being a victim of circumstances.

The sentiment highlights a central theme of accountability versus the randomness of life. The speaker's lack of compassion suggests a belief in personal responsibility, implying that the misfortunes one faces shouldn't necessarily elevate their standing or elicit pity from others. This perspective raises questions about the nature of justice and the role of luck in one's life story.