Mindy Kaling's approach to selecting karaoke songs is influenced by three primary factors. First, she contemplates the message the song conveys about her identity and personal image. This reflection ensures that her song choice aligns with how she wants to be perceived by others.
Additionally, Kaling considers her vocal abilities and whether she can perform the song well enough to be enjoyable. Lastly, she thinks about the emotional reaction her song might evoke in the audience, as making an impact on listeners is a significant part of the karaoke experience for her.