In the book "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close," the characters reflect on the profound connection between beauty and truth in art. The line "Why do beautiful songs make you sad?" emphasizes the bittersweet nature of beauty, suggesting that it evokes sadness because it is often unattainable or fleeting. This sentiment captures the essence of how beautiful creations can serve as reminders of loss or longing.

The response, "Nothing is beautiful and true," highlights a deep skepticism about the coexistence of beauty and truth. It implies that while art can inspire, its beauty is often coupled with a sense of disappointment, revealing a complex relationship where beauty may not align with reality. This dialogue invites readers to ponder the emotional impact of beauty and the truth it may mask.