In Rebecca Goldstein's novel "Mazel," a character presents a surprising revelation about Sherlock Holmes, suggesting that he is actually Jewish and that his name change obscures his true identity. This statement challenges the traditional perception of the iconic detective and highlights the complexities of cultural identity. The remark implies a deeper narrative about how characters can represent various backgrounds, encouraging readers to reconsider their views on literary figures.

This twist not only adds an intriguing layer to the character of Holmes but also reflects broader themes of identity and transformation. Goldstein's commentary invites exploration of how authors infuse personal and cultural history into their creations, prompting audiences to reflect on the significance of names and heritage in defining who we are. The idea that such a well-known character could possess a concealed background serves as a catalyst for discussions around identity in literature.