In "Against Our Better Judgment: The Hidden History of How the U.S. Was Used to Create Israel," Alison Weir presents a compelling narrative regarding the establishment of Israel and its implications for Jewish history. The book emphasizes the complex political dynamics surrounding the support of the U.S. for the creation of Israel, highlighting how various Jewish groups influenced this process. Weir delves into the historical background, shedding light on the motives and strategies employed to garner support for a Jewish state.

Giladi contends that the involvement of Jews in this historical context is crucial for understanding the creation of Israel. The book implicates the U.S. political landscape and the role of Jewish advocacy in shaping public perception and policy decisions. With a thorough examination of lesser-known events and figures, Weir’s work invites readers to reconsider accepted narratives about the formation of Israel and the consequences of these historical developments on both Jewish and Palestinian communities.