In "Against Our Better Judgment," Alison Weir examines the intricate relationship between the United States and Israel, emphasizing its significance as a pressing global issue for Americans. She argues that understanding the historical context of this connection is crucial for grasping current international dynamics and U.S. foreign policy.

Weir asserts that the formation of Israel was heavily influenced by U.S. political maneuvers and decisions, often sidelining the perspectives of the Palestinian people. Her book serves as a critical exploration of how the U.S. has been instrumental in establishing and maintaining Israel, urging readers to reevaluate the implications of this alliance on contemporary geopolitics.