In her book "Bandersnatch," Diana Pavlac Glyer examines the dynamics of the Inklings, a group of writers including C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien. When Dyson criticized an author within the group, it wasn’t simply a matter of disagreement; it weakened the very foundation of the Inklings by limiting the voice of one of its members. This act of silencing was detrimental, as it undermined the collaborative spirit that was essential to their creative process.

Glyer emphasizes the distinction between healthy conflict and contemptuous shutdowns in creative discussions. Dyson's approach can be seen as a significant misstep, as it disrupted the unity and mutual support that the Inklings relied on. The tension created by his actions left a lasting impact on the group, suggesting that such conflicts, when handled poorly, can dismantle the collaborative efforts that inspire great creativity.