The founding of America was marred by the acceptance and growth of slavery, which was seen as a necessary compromise for the nation's formation. This troubling aspect suggests that the tragedy of slavery is woven into the very fabric of American history. The question arises whether this tragedy was fated, akin to Greek tragedies, or if it was a result of choices influenced by the racial prejudices of the nation’s founders.

This dilemma reflects a broader discussion about America's moral and historical legacy. The contrast between an inevitable outcome versus one that could have been altered highlights the complexity of the founding era and the ideals versus the realities faced by the early republic. Thus, it compels us to reexamine the compromises made in pursuit of nationhood and their lasting implications on American society.