In "44 Scotland Street," Alexander McCall Smith expresses a critique of regularity when it lacks a deeper meaning or intrinsic beauty. He suggests that a rigid adherence to order can become unappealing if it is not accompanied by genuine qualities such as character or soul. This viewpoint highlights the importance of authenticity and human messiness over mere structure.

Smith’s reflection suggests that the richness of life comes from its imperfections and complexities rather than from a sterile, perfectly regimented existence. This perspective encourages embracing the chaos of human nature, which often reveals a deeper, more relatable beauty than the coldness of strict regularity.