Someone else is going to read for me or go at my place to the mosque, and/or to tell me you shouldn't take anything from the West because the West is the enemy and so on. It is to me to decide. I am intelligent enough to be critical towards the West and take what I need and reject what is bad for me.
This profound statement grapples with the idea of individual autonomy and critical thinking in the context of cultural influence and ideological rigidity. It highlights the tension between societal or communal pressures to conform and the personal capacity for discernment. The speaker emphasizes personal agency—the power to selectively evaluate ideas and cultural products, rather than accepting or rejecting wholesale.
The quote resonates with the complexity of navigating global cultural exchanges, especially between the West and other parts of the world where attitudes towards Western influence oscillate between admiration and suspicion. Fatema Mernissi wisely asserts her right to engage intellectually and critically with Western culture, challenging the binary perspective of ‘us versus them’ that often simplifies global relations into conflict and opposition. This encourages an independent mindset that neither blindly accepts nor completely rejects external influences.
Moreover, this statement can be seen as an argument for intellectual sovereignty and growth. It asserts that true maturity lies in the ability to sift through cultures and ideas to identify what is beneficial or detrimental personally, culturally, or socially. It also critiques the gatekeeping tendency of some societal voices who presume to limit or dictate what others should believe. By stating "it is to me to decide," Mernissi insists on self-determination.
In a world increasingly interconnected and polarized, this approach advocates for thoughtful, critical engagement and the dismantling of rigid ideological walls. Ultimately, this quote inspires reflection on how we form our beliefs amidst diverse influences and encourages confidence in personal judgment.