The story describes a young boy named Andy who inquires about his father's release from jail. Garcia gently explains that his father will never be released because he shot a man in the eyes, emphasizing the seriousness of the situation. Andy understands the gravity of this revelation, while his sister Lynne offers a different perspective, suggesting there might have been a valid reason behind the shooting.

Garcia dismisses the idea of justification by stating there are a hundred thousand reasons, but none that excuse such an act. Their conversation is abruptly interrupted when Donna, from the kitchen, angrily orders them to be quiet, indicating tension and perhaps a protective or disciplinary attitude. This scene reflects the family's complex feelings about the father's crime and its impact on their lives.