...they'll say, 'He never recovered from that breakdown and this was the result. It had to be the breakdown--not even he was that dreadful a novelist.
In Philip Roth's "Operation Shylock: A Confession," the narrative explores the impact of a personal breakdown on a writer's life and career. Roth reflects on how a critical moment of mental distress can overshadow all subsequent accomplishments, suggesting that people often look for a singular reason to explain a decline in one's abilities or creativity. This breakdown becomes a scapegoat for perceived failures, leading to a skewed interpretation of an artist's trajectory.
The quote highlights the tendency of critics and audiences to simplify a complex creative journey by attributing negative outcomes solely to this moment of crisis. It implies that even if a novelist's later work is subpar, the prevailing sentiment will focus on the breakdown as the definitive factor, diminishing the author's overall reputation without acknowledging the nuanced realities of their experiences.