To lead by force all you need is a greater army, but to lead by example, to be a city on a hill, you need an uncompromising respect for basic dignity. And you don't gain either of those things by breeding monsters in dungeons.
This quote highlights the profound difference between methods of leadership rooted in brute power and those grounded in moral integrity. The analogy suggests that while military might can impose control, true leadership that inspires and sustains societal ideals hinges on respect for human dignity. When leaders rely solely on force, their power is superficial, dependent on tangible strength rather than moral rightful authority. Conversely, leading by example—being a city on a hill—implies setting an aspirational standard that others can follow, grounded in values like justice, compassion, and respect. The metaphor about breeding monsters in dungeons serves as a warning that cultivating fear or chaos in dark, hidden spaces corrupts integrity and erodes the moral foundation necessary for genuine influence. Such practices may produce immediate results but ultimately undermine the very dignity and respect essential for lasting leadership. The quote resonates deeply with the notion that true power is not measured solely by military or coercive might, but by the moral strength and integrity of those who lead. It invites reflection on the importance of nurturing a society based on respect for fundamental human dignity, rather than fear or oppression. In a broader sense, it advocates for leaders and communities to cultivate virtues that promote genuine human flourishing and harmony, warning against destructive practices that breed monsters—be they literal or metaphorical—that threaten societal stability and moral health.
( City of Gods II: Horsemen ) - author: Jonathan Maas
