The quote illustrates the idea that a woman's worth or identity should not be reduced to superficial evaluations or superficial interactions. Comparing a woman to a watermelon suggests that her value can be judged merely by external appearances or initial impressions, which detracts from her complexity and individuality. This metaphor critiques the tendency to objectify women, treating them as objects to be assessed rather than as individuals with their own narratives and experiences.

In "The Marriage Plot," Jeffrey Eugenides emphasizes the importance of understanding and appreciating women beyond their physical attributes or societal roles. The quote serves as a reminder to engage with women as whole persons, recognizing their depth and richness rather than attempting to glean their worth through shallow means. This perspective encourages a more profound appreciation for female characters and relationships within the story, advocating for deeper connections based on understanding and respect.