In "The Secret History" by Donna Tartt, the narrator expresses a strong opinion about religious conversion and its implications. They acknowledge the Roman Catholic Church as a formidable institution, deserving of respect. The narrator conveys a sense of acceptance towards someone potentially converting to Catholicism, indicating that they would find that shift justifiable and even admirable.
However, the narrator's tone shifts to disappointment at the thought of this individual becoming a Presbyterian instead. This reveals a nuanced perspective on religious affiliations, suggesting that the narrator places greater value on the Roman Catholic Church compared to other denominations. Their feelings underline a broader commentary on faith, identity, and the significance of profound beliefs within social dynamics.