The scene of a murder reveals a stark contrast between the natural instincts of cats and the brutal actions of humans. For Joe and Dulcie, the cats, hunting is a fundamental part of their existence, done either for nourishment or training their young. They understand this bloodlust as part of their nature, but when faced with the gruesome act committed by a human, they are confronted with a profound moral degradation that disturbs them deeply. The cats find it difficult to reconcile their view of humans with such senseless violence.

The violent and sadistic tendencies displayed by the human perpetrator unsettle Dulcie, challenging her perception of humanity. While cats may kill instinctively, the motive behind this crime—driven by rage, greed, or cruelty—is unimaginable to them. This realization causes Dulcie significant distress, as it forces her to confront a darker aspect of the human condition that starkly contrasts with the nature of her own species.