In "Housekeeping vs. the Dirt," Nick Hornby expresses a sense of admiration and humility regarding the intellectual prowess of Carey, an individual with extensive reading and a rational mindset. Hornby acknowledges that he, along with many others, lacks the same depth of knowledge and the ability to effectively counter various arguments concerning objective aesthetic principles. This recognition highlights the complexity of aesthetic discussions and the difficulty in establishing universal standards in art and literature.

Hornby's commentary reflects a broader skepticism towards the notion of objective aesthetics, suggesting that the majority of those who engage in these debates may fall short of convincingly arguing their points. Through this critique, he emphasizes the subjective nature of artistic evaluation, as well as the challenges presented by differing opinions. Ultimately, Hornby's insight invites readers to reflect on the personal and varied experiences that shape their understanding of art.