In "Dominion," Matthew Scully argues that viewing animals solely as commodities reduces humans to mere consumers driven by their material desires. This perspective diminishes our sense of responsibility towards other beings and suggests that our existence is centered around satisfying appetites rather than seeking deeper moral values.

Scully’s work urges a reevaluation of how we perceive our relationship with animals, advocating for compassion and mercy instead of a purely exploitative view. By emphasizing the moral implications of our choices, he calls for a greater awareness of the interconnectedness of life and the ethical responsibilities that come with it.