In his book "Dominion," Matthew Scully argues that as moral beings, our choices should be guided by reason and ethics, particularly in relation to animals. He critiques those who prioritize their cravings over the welfare of animals, labeling such attitudes as gluttonous. Scully emphasizes that true humanity lies in recognizing that the suffering of animals holds greater significance than our desire for pleasurable foods.

Scully's perspective challenges us to reflect on our dietary choices and the moral implications that accompany them. He asserts that to be truly humane, we must value compassion and understanding above mere satisfaction of our appetites, suggesting that a shift in our thinking can lead to more ethical decisions regarding the treatment of animals.